I have been grappling with this question for years!

On one hand, I wholeheartedly believe that if you buy subpar items, you get subpar results. However, that isn’t always the case.

I partake in activities that can be done either very inexpensively or at a high cost.

Naturally, I tend to lean towards the latter more often than not.

The High Cost of Quality

For many years, I opted for top-of-the-line equipment.

In some areas, like bow hunting and electronics, I prefer not to take any chances.

Having your bow malfunction when you are at full draw is not something you want happening.

Even worse is your GPS acting up when you are 30 miles offshore or deep in the Everglades.

Part of the cost you pay for high-dollar items is peace of mind.

Look, I am notorious for having champagne dreams on a beer budget—it’s who I am.

But as I have gotten older, I have miraculously gotten wiser.

Case in Point: Fishing Gear

Some years back, I decided I wanted to upgrade all of my rigs that my clients use on fishing charters.

So, I sprang for some new St. Croix rods and Shimano Stradics.

St. Croix has always made incredible rods, and I will continue using them until they don’t.

I have beaten the living hell out of them since I started using them in 1994.

I have broken two in all of those years.

One was in a door, and the other was stepped on by a client right after I told him not to put the rods on the deck.

The Unexpected Failures

Anyway, I got these new setups and put them into service.

Within two months, the bail came off of two of my reels, and a handle snapped off of another.

I was not happy, to say the least.

So, after talking to one of my buddies, who is also a guide, he let me in on a little secret.

He told me that he stopped buying expensive reels years ago and hasn’t looked back.

He mentioned he hasn’t had to replace one in quite a few years.

The Test: Affordable Reels

I had a hard time believing him, but I was going to check it out.

So, I ordered a few of Okuma’s lower-end reels, loaded them with line, and put them on some rods.

I put them to the test immediately by getting into some giant snook and hefty redfish. They did not disappoint!

Smooth drags, sturdy, and no problem getting the job done.

Testing them in the Glades was fine and all, but I needed to know they could really handle some heat.

So, I headed to the Keys.

The Keys Challenge

After getting into some fat bonefish and small permit, I was sold 100%. The reels had no problem putting the brakes on a runaway bonefish.

I have watched reels literally explode over the years from the blistering runs of a bonefish. After that trip, I ordered those reels for all of my setups.

It has been close to eight years since I decided to “downgrade” my reels, and I have zero regrets.

I wish I would have known that sooner—it would have saved me a lot of money that could have been spent on something else.

Broadened Horizons

Since this awakening, I try to do this with everything I am going to buy.

I do extensive research before pulling the trigger.

Sure, there are some things I am just too brand loyal to part ways with, but I have definitely broadened my horizons—not just in the fishing and hunting world.

I have bought some tools from Harbor Freight that have outlasted the biggest brand names.

Electronics: Navigating the Waters

When it comes to electronics, the stakes can be even higher.

I’ve always been a stickler for having the best GPS and fish finders on my boat.

After all, navigating the waters safely is paramount, and knowing where the fish are can make or break a trip.

Gear: From Clothing to Accessories

Let’s not forget about clothing and accessories.

Over the years, I’ve spent a small fortune on branded gear, convinced that the expensive tags would keep me warmer, drier, and ultimately more comfortable in the wild.

While there’s some truth to the benefits of high-quality gear, I’ve found that mid-range brands often offer comparable comfort and durability at a fraction of the cost.

Tools of the Trade

Another area where I’ve applied this newfound wisdom is with tools.

As someone who enjoys DIY projects and occasional repairs, having reliable tools is crucial. Initially, I always opted for the most expensive brands, believing they were the only ones that would stand the test of time.

However, after some advice from a fellow DIY enthusiast, I decided to give Harbor Freight tools a try.

To my surprise, many of their tools have outperformed some of the high-end brands I used to swear by.

They’ve proven to be durable, effective, and significantly more affordable.

This has allowed me to expand my tool collection without breaking the bank.

The Lesson Learned

What all these experiences have taught me is the importance of doing thorough research and being open-minded.

Expensive doesn’t always mean better, and there are plenty of high-quality, cost-effective options available if you’re willing to look.

Whether it’s fishing gear, hunting equipment, or outdoor apparel, taking the time to explore different brands and read reviews can save you a significant amount of money without compromising on quality.

Final Thoughts

If you are in the market for something and typically opt for the most expensive, do yourself and your wallet a favor and look around.

There is so much information out there about everything.

It won’t take you long, and it will only benefit you in the long run.

The reels I replaced were around $150 a piece.

I was able to get three reels for that price. Do your homework and make informed decisions—you’ll be glad you did.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the allure of expensive, top-of-the-line gear is undeniable, it’s essential to remember that higher cost doesn’t always equate to higher quality or better performance.

By being open to trying less expensive alternatives and doing thorough research, you can find equipment that meets your needs without draining your wallet.

This approach has not only saved me money but has also broadened my horizons and improved my overall experience in both fishing and hunting.

Hope you enjoyed this post! If you have any experiences or tips about buying gear, drop a comment below. Tight lines and happy hunting!

Capt. Vince Bini